Best Overall
New Star 16" Wood Peel
Key details
- Weight
- 426g
- Material
- Basswood
- Blade Size
- 14" x 16"
- Thickness / Bevel
- —
The New Star 16-inch wood peel gives you a wide 14x16-inch blade that handles up to 16-inch pizzas and rectangular breads with ease, all at a price that undercuts most competitors. Its lightweight basswood construction makes slide-ins and retrievals feel effortless, which is why it has become the go-to choice for Ooni oven owners and home bakers alike.
The tradeoff is that the blade arrives unfinished — the surface can be rough enough to snag dough, and some boards warp if they aren't seasoned with oil. This makes it best suited for home cooks who are comfortable spending 15 minutes with sandpaper before first use and applying oil periodically. For casual pizza nights or weekend bread baking, the size and value are hard to beat; for someone looking for a ready-to-use peel with zero maintenance, other options like the Epicurean composite board may be a better fit.
💡 Sand the blade before first use and oil regularly to maintain the surface and prevent warping.
Pros
- 16x14-inch blade fits large round pizzas and rectangular breads.
- Lightweight enough to slide loaded pizzas in and out without strain.
- Cost-effective for the size, delivering solid function at a mid-range price.
Cons
- The blade surface can arrive rough enough to catch dough, requiring sanding before first use.
- Without regular oiling, the wood may warp or crack after a few uses.
If you're willing to sand and oil it, this peel delivers the largest functional surface at the lowest cost — ideal for home pizza makers who value size over instant readiness.